Credit: Illustration: Daria Hlazatova for Spiral Magazine, Rubin Museum of Art (New York)
When it comes to survival of the fittest, change is the only constant In 1973 the evolutionary biologist Leigh Van Valen quoted Lewis Carroll’s Red Queen as a metaphor to explain what he viewed as the main driver of the diversification and extinction of species: the struggle of life itself. The Red Queen hypothesis argues that species must constantly adapt—or “run” in the queen’s words—as a survival mechanism. The constant competition for resources is what keeps us running. When one species becomes better at acquiring resources, the other species must adapt to keep up—“to keep in the same place.” This cancels out the long-term advantage of the adaptation in a single species.
The Red Queen hypothesis relies on the understanding that biotic interactions underlie the evolution and extinction of species. Although Red Queen dynamics seem to be mostly limited to short timescales (less than one hundred thousand years), there are examples attesting to the role of biotic forces as an evolutionary driver over long timescales.
While in the Red Queen hypothesis, intrinsic traits pertaining to or originating from inside an organism or cell are the major drivers of biodiversity, in the Court Jester theory, extrinsic abiotic factors—things related to the physical environment, like climate change, tectonics, or extraterrestrial impacts—play a more important role in shaping the diversity of life.
Court Jester hypotheses imply that shifts in the physical environment can change the rules imposed by biotic interactions. Thus an important difference between the Red Queen and Court Jester models of evolution is the timescale in which they seem to happen. Court Jester processes are known to prevail at longer timescales than the Red Queen dynamic, at over one hundred thousand years...
Extract of article by Julia Tejada for the Spiral Magazine, Rubin Museum of Art (Impermanence issue)
Complete article at https://rubinmuseum.org/spiral/a-royal-duel-in-the-natural-world/